Facebook
X
Pinterest
Copy Link
Buying your first home in the Bay Area can feel overwhelming, but if you’re searching for the best neighborhoods for first-time homebuyers in San Mateo County, you might be surprised by how many great options exist. You don’t need to overextend to find a home you love. There are several neighborhoods across San Mateo County that quietly offer value, livability, and long-term potential for first-time buyers. Some are tucked away in well-established communities. Others are up-and-coming and poised for growth.
Let’s start with one of the best: The Village in San Mateo, and expand to five other communities worth exploring.
The Village – San Mateo
Why it’s great: The Village offers a small-town feel with urban conveniences. Nestled between Hillsdale Shopping Center and Highway 92, this tight-knit neighborhood is walkable, peaceful, and full of charm. Neighbors greet each other. Kids ride bikes to Casanova Park. And residents are only minutes from Caltrain, Whole Foods, and Hillsdale Mall.
What you’ll find here: Well-kept mid-century homes, often single-level with detached garages and private backyards. Many have been updated over the years, offering move-in-ready comfort with long-term upside.
- View current listings in this neighborhood
Bonus: You’re zoned for strong public schools and can walk to local favorites like Esposto’s or the San Mateo Library branch.
North Shoreview offers easy access to peaceful shoreline trails, making it a favorite for nature lovers and first-time homebuyers alike.
North Shoreview – San Mateo
Why it’s great: Located just east of downtown and bordered by Coyote Point and the Bay Trail, North Shoreview blends affordability with access to nature. You’ll find a community vibe, easy freeway access, and surprisingly good walkability with parks, schools, and even a golf course nearby.
What you’ll find here: A mix of mid-century homes, newer infill, and a few townhomes. Many properties have large lots, giving you room to grow.
- View current listings in this neighborhood
Bonus: Spend your weekends at Coyote Point Recreation Area or walk the shoreline trail with views of the Bay and SFO jets flying overhead.
Sterling Downs offers a peaceful, residential setting with hillside views and close proximity to schools, parks, and local shops.
Sterling Downs – Belmont
Why it’s great: Belmont is known for its hillside homes and excellent schools, but Sterling Downs is the pocket where first-time buyers still have a shot. Located on the eastern side of Belmont, it offers flat streets, friendly neighbors, and quick access to both 101 and Ralston Ave.
What you’ll find here: Mostly single-level ranch-style homes, many with original hardwood floors and attached garages. Some have already been expanded or modernized.
- View current listings in this neighborhood
Bonus: You’re walking distance to Nesbit Elementary and close to local gems like Waterdog Lake trails and the Belmont Farmers Market.
Redwood Oaks and Friendly Acres offer close-knit neighborhoods, diverse housing, and quick access to downtown Redwood City.
Redwood Oaks & Friendly Acres – Redwood City
Why they’re great: These adjacent neighborhoods are quietly growing in popularity. They’re centrally located between downtown Redwood City and tech campuses, with easy access to Costco, Marsh Manor, and Highway 101. Buyers love the diverse housing styles and the increasing number of updated homes.
What you’ll find here: A mix of older homes, bungalows, and a growing number of new-build townhomes and remodels. You’ll also find ADUs and multi-gen setups.
- View current listings in this neighborhood
Bonus: Downtown Redwood City is a few minutes away, with a movie theater, summer concerts, and some of the best dining in the county.
Edgewater in Foster City offers tranquil waterfront living, scenic trails, and easy access to major employers and retail centers.
Edgewater Area – Foster City
Why it’s great: Foster City is built for lifestyle, and Edgewater puts you in the center of it. Think waterfront paths, pocket parks, and award-winning schools, all within a master-planned community. It’s walkable, scenic, and peaceful, a perfect blend for young families or professionals.
What you’ll find here: Attached townhomes, mid-sized single-family homes, and some waterfront properties. Many communities come with HOA amenities like pools or tennis courts.
- View current listings in this neighborhood
Bonus: Walk to Edgewater Park, Leo J. Ryan Park, or paddleboard on the lagoon. Commuting to SF or the South Bay? You’re halfway to both.
Millbrae Meadows residents gather early for Millbrae Goes to the Movies, a summer tradition that brings neighbors together for a night of family fun.
The Meadows – Millbrae
Why it’s great: This westside Millbrae neighborhood sits close to BART, top-rated schools, and downtown shops, yet maintains a tucked-away, residential vibe. It’s a popular starting point for buyers seeking great public schools without moving too far south.
What you’ll find here: Classic 3-bed ranch-style homes with spacious yards and quiet streets. Some fixer-uppers remain, while others are updated and move-in ready.
- View current listings in this neighborhood
Bonus: Commute to the city via BART or Caltrain and enjoy brunch on Broadway or a hike at Sawyer Camp Trail.
Final Thoughts
Buying your first home isn’t just about getting in the market, it’s about landing somewhere you’ll thrive. These are some of the best neighborhoods for first-time homebuyers in San Mateo County based on affordability, schools, and transit access. “The Village” and these five other neighborhoods offer more than just a house. They offer a foothold into San Mateo County life.
Want a local’s perspective on which neighborhood fits your lifestyle and goals best? I’d love to walk you through the options, show you what’s available including off-market opportunities, and build a plan that sets you up for long-term success.
